39 matches (23W 7D 9L), goals: 72-37
Copa America 1945, Copa America 1947, Copa America 1957, Copa America 1963, Independence 1972, South American Games 1986, Copa America 1987, Copa America 1991, Copa America 1993, Copa America 1999, Copa America 2004, Copa America 2007, Copa America 2011, Copa America 2015, Copa America 2019
| 07 FEB 1945 | Argentina - Colombia | 9:1 | Copa America |
| 18 DEC 1947 | Argentina - Colombia | 6:0 | Copa America |
| 13 MAR 1957 | Argentina - Colombia | 8:2 | Copa America |
| 10 MAR 1963 | Argentina - Colombia | 4:2 | Copa America |
| 22 JUN 1972 | Argentina - Colombia | 4:1 | Independence |
| 24 AUG 1984 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:0 | Friendly |
| 02 JUN 1985 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:3 | World Cup Quals |
| 16 JUN 1985 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 24 NOV 1986 | Argentina - Colombia | 3:1 | South American Games |
| 06 DEC 1986 | Argentina - Colombia | 2:0 | South American Games |
| 11 JUL 1987 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:2 | Copa America |
| 09 MAR 1989 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:0 | Friendly |
| 21 JUL 1991 | Argentina - Colombia | 2:1 | Copa America |
| 23 JUN 1993 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:1 | Copa America |
| 01 JUL 1993 | Argentina - Colombia | p.6:5 | Copa America |
| 15 AUG 1993 | Colombia - Argentina | 2:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 05 SEP 1993 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:5 | World Cup Quals |
| 11 OCT 1995 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:0 | Friendly |
| 12 FEB 1997 | Colombia - Argentina | 0:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 16 NOV 1997 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 04 JUL 1999 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:3 | Copa America |
| 13 OCT 1999 | Argentina - Colombia | 2:1 | Friendly |
| 29 JUN 2000 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:3 | World Cup Quals |
| 03 JUN 2001 | Argentina - Colombia | 3:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 18 NOV 2003 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 27 JUN 2004 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:2 | Friendly |
| 20 JUL 2004 | Argentina - Colombia | 3:0 | Copa America |
| 30 MAR 2005 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 02 JUL 2007 | Argentina - Colombia | 4:2 | Copa America |
| 20 NOV 2007 | Colombia - Argentina | 2:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 06 JUN 2009 | Argentina - Colombia | 1:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 06 JUL 2011 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:0 | Copa America |
| 15 NOV 2011 | Colombia - Argentina | 1:2 | World Cup Quals |
| 07 JUN 2013 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 26 JUN 2015 | Argentina - Colombia | p.5:4 | Copa America |
| 17 NOV 2015 | Colombia - Argentina | 0:1 | World Cup Quals |
| 15 NOV 2016 | Argentina - Colombia | 3:0 | World Cup Quals |
| 11 SEP 2018 | Colombia - Argentina | 0:0 | Friendly |
| 15 JUN 2019 | Argentina - Colombia | 0:2 | Copa America |